HIRA Vs JSA Explained with 10 Examples of Each

HIRA Vs JSA Explained with 10 Examples of Each

Introduction

Workplace safety is a top priority in every industry, and two essential tools for risk assessment are HIRA (Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment) and JSA (Job Safety Analysis). While both aim to prevent accidents and ensure worker safety, they have different applications. This article explains the key differences and provides real-world examples of each.

What is HIRA?

HIRA (Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment) is a process used to identify, assess, and control workplace hazards at a broader level. It evaluates potential risks in a specific workplace or process before work begins.

10 Examples of HIRA Applications

1. Identifying fire hazards in an oil refinery – Analyzing flammable substances and fire prevention strategies.
2. Assessing electrical risks in a power plant – Evaluating the risk of electrocution and implementing safety measures.
3. Evaluating chemical hazards in a laboratory – Identifying toxic or reactive substances and ensuring proper storage.
4. Identifying fall hazards at a construction site – Reviewing scaffolding, ladder safety, and fall protection.
5. Assessing confined space entry risks – Ensuring proper ventilation, monitoring oxygen levels, and using PPE.
6. Evaluating machine hazards in a manufacturing plant – Identifying pinch points, rotating parts, and safeguarding measures.
7. Identifying ergonomic risks in an office setting – Assessing workstation setup, chair positioning, and repetitive strain injuries.
8. Assessing biological hazards in a hospital – Identifying infection risks, needle safety, and hygiene protocols.
9. Identifying transport and vehicle risks in a warehouse – Evaluating forklift operation, pedestrian safety, and traffic control.
10. Evaluating noise hazards in an industrial facility – Measuring decibel levels and recommending hearing protection.

What is JSA?

JSA (Job Safety Analysis) is a task-specific risk assessment that breaks down a job into individual steps, identifies hazards, and determines safety measures for each step.

10 Examples of JSA Applications

1. Safe operation of heavy machinery – Identifying risks and ensuring proper machine guarding.
2. Welding in a confined space – Ensuring proper ventilation, fire safety, and PPE use.
3. Handling hazardous chemicals safely – Implementing proper labeling, storage, and handling techniques.
4. Working at heights using scaffolding – Ensuring fall protection and secure anchoring.
5. Lockout/tagout procedures for electrical work – Preventing accidental energy release during maintenance.
6. Safe lifting and material handling techniques – Reducing the risk of back injuries and strains.
7. Using power tools in construction – Ensuring proper handling, guarding, and PPE use.
8. Excavation and trenching safety – Identifying cave-in hazards and ensuring proper shoring.
9. Fire watch duties in hot work operations – Monitoring for fire hazards and having extinguishing equipment ready.
10. Safe operation of forklifts in a warehouse – Avoiding collisions, tipping, and pedestrian hazards.

Key Differences Between HIRA and JSA

Feature	HIRA	JSA
Definition	Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment	Job Safety Analysis
Focus	Workplace-wide hazards	Task-specific hazards
Scope	Broad, covering entire processes	Narrow, focusing on job steps
Examples	Fire risks, chemical hazards, ergonomic risks	Welding safety, machine operation, working at heights
Frequency	Conducted periodically or before new projects	Conducted before specific tasks

When to Use HIRA and When to Use JSA?

• Use HIRA when evaluating risks in a workplace, process, or large-scale operation.
• Use JSA when analyzing risks related to a specific job or task.

How to Conduct HIRA and JSA Effectively

Steps for HIRA:

1. Identify hazards in the workplace.
2. Assess the severity and likelihood of risks.
3. Implement control measures (engineering, administrative, PPE).
4. Monitor and review risks periodically.

Steps for JSA:

1. Break down the job into steps.
2. Identify hazards in each step.
3. Determine safety measures for each hazard.
4. Train workers and implement controls.

Conclusion

Both HIRA and JSA play vital roles in workplace safety. HIRA focuses on broader risk assessments, while JSA ensures specific job tasks are performed safely. Understanding when and how to use each method helps prevent accidents and creates a safer work environment.

What Is a Risk Matrix? (2025 Guide With Example)

3×3 Risk Assessment Matrix

5×5 Risk Assessment Matrix

Who Should Perform a Risk Assessment?

---

FAQs

1. What is the biggest difference between HIRA and JSA?
HIRA assesses hazards in a workplace or process, while JSA focuses on specific job tasks.

2. Can HIRA and JSA be used together?
Yes, they complement each other. HIRA identifies general risks, while JSA focuses on task-specific safety.

3. Who is responsible for conducting HIRA and JSA?
Safety officers, supervisors, and employees trained in risk assessment.

4. How often should HIRA and JSA be updated?
HIRA should be reviewed periodically, while JSA should be updated before each job.

5. Why is risk assessment crucial in workplaces?
It helps prevent accidents, ensures compliance, and promotes a safe working environment.